Transcoding FLAC to Ogg Vorbis

Last night I hit a dilemma; a very old CD I ripped to FLAC and now can't find was playable only on certain players, not my Android phone (despite FLAC support) and behaving strange on many desktop players.

Usually I just use something like oggenc -q 4 *.flac since vorbis-tools supports FLAC as a source format (and preserves metadata like artist, title, etc). Strangely, oggenc didn't recognize the files in this album.

GStreamer to the rescue; for file in *.flac; do gst-launch-0.10 filesrc location="$file" ! decodebin ! audioconvert ! vorbisenc quality=0.4 ! oggmux ! filesink location="$file.ogg"; done;

Even though its much slower and more complicated, this should have done the trick. It didn't, and ogginfo showed that the Ogg muxer in GStreamer has some issues;

WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 218558 to 205632
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 666174 to 655680
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 3150206 to 3142208
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 3605054 to 3597376
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 3828670 to 3822400
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 4741630 to 4733312
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 5636158 to 5630784
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 5858494 to 5854208
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 6096126 to 6090560
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 6317758 to 6314048
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 7668798 to 7665088
WARNING: granulepos in stream 1 decreases from 7902718 to 7898240

So with GStreamer not an option, I looked at the original FLAC files and found that whatever encoder I used added ID3 tags (which are not part of the FLAC spec). A quick ID3 removal command stripped these out so oggenc would recognize the files and work;

find . -name "*.flac" -exec id3v2 --delete-all {} \;
oggenc -q 4 *.flac

Done.